Thursday, January 28, 2010

Making a Move for Dion Phaneuf

I think we all can say that this team has officially hit rock bottom, and it doesn't seem like they will be picking themselves up anytime soon. Let's face it, no matter how often the coach says they have to keep at it, no matter how often players tell you it is time to start from "square one" (a phrase I despise), this season is over as long as the inability to score goals persists. The Rangers are comprised of a squad of players that lacks the ability to finish, and if they someway find themselves in the playoffs come April, there is a snowball's chance in hell they come out of the first round victorious.

Now it is time to put this season behind us, realizing there is no use in attempting to make the playoffs at this point, and wait for GM Glen Sather to rebuild. While the major problem right now may be offense, Slats needs to start on the blueline. Wade Redden and Michal Rozsival are obviously dead weight on the Rangers salary cap, and at least one of them needs to be unloaded to begin the rebuilding process. I would say Chris Drury as well, but he has a no movement clause and is not going anywhere until it is waived, which I do not see happening. Redden has actually not looked terrible this season and I believe that benching last night against the Hurricanes was unnecessary. However, his salary is much to large for what he contributes and the same goes for Rozsival.

Well today, our friend Joe Fortunato at Blueshirt Banter brought up the possibility of acquiring Flames defenseman Dion Phaneuf. At age 24, Phaneuf is one of the more established blue-liners in the game and certainly knows how to use the body. He is solid in his own end and great on offense. Dion has a cap hit of $6.5 million, the same as Redden, but is much more effective. He already has nine goals on the season, 21 points total. This would end up being one of Glen Sather's better trades in his tenure with New York.

The reason Joe picked Phaneuf out of all defensemen in the league is because there is a strong rumor out there that GM Darryl Sutter will have Phaneuf traded by the trade deadline in March. The Flames are falling apart and descending in the standings. They just cannot capture wins, and supposedly Dion cannot stand to be a part of the club anymore and has requested a trade. Phaneuf and Sutter have denied the rumor, but various general managers around the league claim they have spoken to the Flames about acquiring the 6-3 stalwart on defense.

It may not be easy, but it is worth a try and would be a move that would benefit the team in the future. If it means trading away Bobby Sanguinetti in a package with current NHLers, then so be it. We are all sick and tired of watching this soft as cotton defense take the ice night in and night out, and Phaneuf would certainly do his part in toughening it up. In fact, I could even see him dropping the gloves with Carcillo after the whole Gaborik incident. I think the fans here would get to like him quickly--the only problem would be convincing Sean Avery after what happened between the two last season, but tough, they would have to settle their differences.

Read Joe's Article Here
(Photo courtesy of Reuters)

8 comments:

So.Long.Scarecrow said...

Avery & Phaneuf on the same team? Would be worth watching lol

NYR Blogger said...

sure would

peo said...

The way I saw it, last night's 3rd goal against the rangers was Matt Gilroy's fault. He flails around on the ice trying to block the pass on (yet another) odd man rush, then tries (not too hard it seemed) and fails to get over to cover his man (the guys who ends up scoring the tip-in. redden blows, but this team has deep seaded issues that go far beyond a seemingly delicious defensive trade.

NYR Blogger said...

Yes the third goal was definitely on Gilroy. Also, obviously there is a lot more to be done than just a trade like this one, but this would be a good start to turning things around with this franchise.

Kingfish said...

A very bad, Rangeresque move. The team is not patchable. It must be dismantled unless the goal is to keep alive a string of making the playoffs with no hope of ever winning the cup. Besides, Phaneuf does play with the same verve that he did before he got his retirement contract. NYR already have too many retirees on the payroll. I say, let them find there own level (i.e., somewhere near last) then they will enjoy a few years of good drafting with Gordie Clark running the show. Everyone other than Garorik, Dubinski, Callahan, Stall and Lunquist should be made available but no one other than Redden or Drury should be given away. When things heat up around 3/1, other teams will overpay rental fees for these spare parts. Then the NYR will start to rebuild because that is really the only way it can be done in the post lockout, cap constrained NHL of today.

NYR Blogger said...

W'ell see what happens. This trade deadline SHOULD be an active one from a Rangers standpoint. They should be looking to sell.

chris said...

i think in order to salvage this season and make a decent run at the playoffs,they need to get a goal scorer....unload drury(no movement clause)rosival,brashearnad some of the younger guys to get someone decent..one goal agst carolina is not cutting it!!!

NYR Blogger said...

There is no doubt they ned a goal scorer, but I am afraid that might not come until the summer. We shall see.

Post a Comment

NOTE: As much as we do not mind readers expressing negativity in their comments, we would still like to maintain a PG-13 environment here on the blog, so please keep it clean and mature. If we feel that a specific comment is inappropriate or offensive in any way, it will be removed. Thank You. -NYR Blogger