AP Photo |
This likely will not fly with fans, but believe it or not, I believe that the Rangers' best option this year would be to do absolutely nothing, zilch, nada on July 1st. Aside from Marian Gaborik, Slats' free agent acquisitions since the lockout have very rarely worked out and has left this team in severe cap trouble. Let's take a moment to look at what exactly I am referring to when I say this; here are some free agent signings by Glen over the recent years.
Wade Redden - member of present team
Chris Drury - member of present team
Ales Kotalik - traded to Calgary
Chris Higgins - traded to Calgary
Scott Gomez - traded to Montreal
Dmitri Kalinin - traded to Phoenix
Marcus Naslund - lost to retirement
Vinny Prospal - will become free agent
Patrick Rissmiller - waived
Aaron Voros - waived
Marian Gaborik - member of present team
Donald Brashear - waived
When you look at that list of individuals, how many of them can you honestly say have been successful on Broadway? I would say Gaborik, Prospal, and probably Marcus Naslund (scored 25 goals with NYR). So that means only three out of the last twelve signings have paid off, putting the success rate at approximately 17 percent. If the odds are that low, and will continue to get lower I am quite sure, why even continue to take the chance?
Head coach John Tortorella told the media at prospect development camp that three positions the Rangers would like to get stronger at are center, defense, and back-up goaltending. I shall begin with center, which there are numerous replacement options other than a free agent. Derek Stepan, Chris Kreider, Ryan Bourque, Ethan Werek, and Evgeny Grachev. Guess what all of those players have in common? First off, there are all top prospects within the Blueshirts' system, and secondly they all play the center position. With a list of centers as deep as that, along with current centers Artem Anisimov and Brandon Dubinsky, I do not see why the club needs a free agent to improve up the middle.
Stepan and Kreider will have a shot at the making the Rangers out of camp later this summer. Grachev, Bourqe and Werek will have that opportunity the next year. With that, New York is just two or three years away from being one of the deepest teams in the entire National Hockey League at center and the best part? They are all coming in as rookies so they will be dirt cheap.
As for defense, sure, an Anton Volchenkov would be nice, but also costly. You know who will not be as costly? Ryan McDonagh, Pavel Valentenko, Corey Potter, Dylan McIlrath, Mike Sauer, Tomas Kundratek,
Again, no free agents needed to fill holes if they build within their system and go with homegrown talent. And yes, again it all comes at a cheap price.
And finally back-up goaltending, the last area of the roster Torts mentioned needs improvement. This is the only area I think the Rangers can turn to the free agent pool and be happy with their decision in the future. Of course, they can also decide to go with goalies that have developed in Hartford (AHL) such as Matt Zaba or Chad Johnson. Now I will admit, I am not a goaltending expert, but Chad Johnson is on his way to becoming a solid netminder in the NHL, but probably not this year. I could certainly see him as Henrik Lundqvist's back-up somewhere down the road.
The "staying the course" approach is not a bad idea for GM Glen Sather and the Rangers' brass. Staying within their system would most likely result in a horrid 2010-11 season, but it will pay off in the year after that and so on. I know that will not satisfy fans, and probably not Sather either, so I do not expect it to happen. However, it is their best option moving forward at the moment.
What do you think the Rangers' approach in free agency should be? Submit your vote in the new poll on the left sidebar.